A Cold and a Broken Hosanna: How Jesus Fails to Meet our Expectations
For nearly 30 years, Randy has been planting churches and engaging with grassroots initiatives in Victoria, BC. He has also worked at the local street church/food bank, taught as a sessional instructor, and has recently taken on a regional position with Vision Ministries Canada. Randy is passionate about revitalizing communities around restorative justice, the local Victoria arts scene, and has a longsuffering relationship with his beloved Canucks.
Kids are chasing each other around, ‘sword fighting’ with the cedar branches that we just handed them. I try to corral these little warriors, seeking to control that which simply won’t be controlled. Sigh. This is how our church’s Palm Sunday ‘processional’ begins. It’s not a Biblical purist’s re-creation (cedars, not palm trees, are in abundance on the West Coast), but as our worship musicians find their groove, eventually the whacking and screaming are replaced by some semblance of dancing and singing. It’s glorious chaos, and I’m happy to report that no one lost an eye.
It does get me thinking about the historical event we are celebrating, though. Over the years, many of us have learnt how to temper our playful pageantry at Christmastide to embrace a grittier, more realistic nativity. Perhaps it’s time to place Palm Sunday under the same scrutiny.
The raw data we’ve been given is good: people have lined the streets of Jerusalem to celebrate the coming of King Jesus, chanting ‘Hosanna’ and ‘Blessed be the King of Israel’. It’s a hopeful and inspiring scene, and the worship songs we sing today do this part justice. But there is something more going on here than a lovely coronation parade, and if we don’t see the proverbial storm brewing, we may be missing the point.
For example, what’s wrong with the throngs calling Jesus the King of Israel? Absolutely nothing, except that they already have one. And this word hosanna (deliver us) was more rightly heard as a political slogan than a personal confession. And do take note: these words are being shouted forcefully, not sung blissfully.
We begin to see the picture emerge: these folks aren’t asking Jesus to save them from their sin, but to liberate them from the tyranny of Rome, the corruption of Herod, and to redeem Israel from thousands of years of conquest, enslavement, exile, and occupation.
If I were a film director trying to capture the mood of this scene, this is the part where the movie’s soundtrack would move from gloriously rousing to something more ominous. The camera that’s been panning the large animated crowd would now zoom onto individual faces, and we would realize that many of these people aren’t smiling: they’re baring their teeth.
Given their history, who could blame them? They expect Jesus to be a military conqueror and a political juggernaut, and, believing that God is on their side, they envision an impending uprising. “It’s only a matter of time,” they must be thinking, “before the Messiah calls us to arms. And when he does, we’ll be ready.”
But now the camera falls on the face of the man on the donkey. Jesus isn’t smiling and raising his arms in victory as he enters Jerusalem. There are tears in his eyes because he knows what they want and he knows who he is.
In the course of six days, the verdict will become clear: the hands that held palm branches on Sunday will be the very same hands making fists on Friday. The voices shouting “Hosanna!” will be hollering, “Give us Barabbas instead!”
… the camera fades to black.
Sometimes I wonder: Has anything really changed?
Several years ago, Canadians witnessed a failed violent uprising south of the border, with some ‘Christian patriots’ literally bearing the Prince of Peace’s name on their fettered banners. But this example is low-hanging fruit and only proves that we can use Jesus’ name to justify just about anything. Besides, it’s missing the point.
The fact is, most of us have self-interests that we justify in Jesus’ name. Too often, our understanding of Jesus being “for us” involves an impulse to believe that Jesus is “against them”. When we lift these tainted hosannas, Jesus dies a thousand deaths, and we become no different than the misguided dissidents in Jerusalem two thousand years ago.
Conversely, we can try to depoliticize Jesus, but he’ll have none of it. The kingdom he inaugurated through his death and resurrection isn’t simply an inner-peace “serenity now” kinda thing, but a social reality that we are called to participate in together. In contrast to the partisan idolatry and polarizing insanity that we have conjured in these troubled times, the goal of this ‘gospel-soaked’ kingdom is the reconciliation of all people. This can’t happen through strong-armed coercion or contemptible cancelling, but only through solidarity with those who are suffering, practicing hospitality toward all people, and living for the sake of others.
Palm Sunday is a test for us. It lays all our agendas bare.
As we enter the final week of this Lenten season, I pray that we will do a deep-dive examination of our fearful motivations and ill-placed allegiances. May we find God’s good graces there. May we then tune our ears to the new song that Jesus is singing, raise our palm branches (or, in our case, cedar branches), and find the ‘hosanna’ that truly saves us.
Thank you for reading the New Leaf Lent Series, a collection of reflections from writers across Canada. If you are enjoying the reader, sign up to receive the readings in your inbox each day here: SIGN UP
And please share this reflection with your friends and family who might also enjoy it.
Read more posts for Lent
In the spring, I’m a rugby coach. I’m also a lot of other things, but in the spring, I live in my rugby sweatshirt. I love the smell of the earth—the dirt softening and giving way to grass. I love that it is a sport that draws together an eclectic group of players, a few who are naturally athletic or have played other sports, but also many for whom this is it, a hodgepodge of misfits finding a place to belong…
I recently attended my first “Forest Church” service. The conservation area where it was hosted was one of the most beautiful sanctuaries I have ever gathered in. The snow was melting, and the creek was rushing with its runoff, creating a background rhythm, which was joined by a gentle breeze whistling through the trees and accompanied by a choir of birds singing their choruses…
Kids are chasing each other around, ‘sword fighting’ with the cedar branches that we just handed them. I try to corral these little warriors, seeking to control that which simply won’t be controlled. Sigh. This is how our church’s Palm Sunday ‘processional’ begins…
Like many others have expressed in their reflections, the Lenten season has a special place in my being. It coincides nicely with the darkest time of the year, during which I often find myself heavily stressed and depressed. Every year, old wounds and new wounds find themselves out in the open, and God invites me on another journey towards healing…
In 2017, I lost two grandparents within months of each other. With my 嫲嫲 (paternal grandmother), the news was not unexpected. She had been ill for quite some time, slowly deteriorating in the hospital…
I am writing during a Sabbatical pause from work and ministry,
And this is a dangerous place.
I’ve been thinking and reflecting and longing and feeling a LOT lately…
For the past few years, I have slowly been making my way through Robert Alter’s translation (with commentary) of the Hebrew Bible, and it just so happened that I began the book of Job in mid-January. Job can be a difficult book for many reasons, but, somewhat surprisingly, I have found the Job poet’s words to be particularly relevant and meaningful as I journey through Lent this year…
Over the years, the story of Jesus washing his disciple’s feet has captivated my imagination. A few years ago, Jesus’ response (“Unless I wash you, you have no part with me.”) to Peter’s declaration that Jesus would NEVER wash his feet caught my attention as I pondered what it means to be willing to receive…
What do you want to do with your one and only life?
Be your true, authentic self!
Live from the centre of who you truly are!
These kinds of over-sized enthusiastic questions and maxims are what greet people like me who live in the liminal space of trying to decide what to do next…
Lent is a season of preparation and a time to remember Jesus’ journey to Golgotha so that we can celebrate Jesus’ resurrection with great joy. I observed a fast and other spiritual disciplines during Lent for many years. Yet, I’ve struggled to find a meaningful Lenten practice to observe this year…
The early years of my spiritual formation happened in a large Evangelical Pentecostal church in the little city of Guelph, Ontario. During the 90s, Lent was not a season that we spoke about or practiced in our faith tradition. We certainly wished no ill will towards our mainline brothers and sisters, but I always had the impression that we were at best suspicious…
I woke up this morning with the weight of the world on my chest. I have learned to listen with compassion to these weights, but this morning, the weight is mysterious. I can’t quite point to one cause…
That little whisper in my ear or a feeling in my gut that says there is not enough to go around. I need to fight for my share. My fear that something that can’t be healed will happen to my kids. My tendency to overestimate and project far into the future the negative consequence of one small action (or inaction). These are the ways that the accuser uses temptations in my life…
“Each morning comes along and you assume it will be similar enough to the previous one – that you will be safe, that your family will be alive, that you will be together, that life will remain mostly as it was.”
That’s from Cloud Cuckoo Land, American author Anthony Doerr’s new book.
“Then a moment arrives and everything changes” (64).
In Cloud Cuckoo Land, the world ends roughly five times…
I’m yanking persistent weeds through the black shroud covering last summer’s flower beds. It’s Good Friday. Steve, who has only 15 days left to live, is sitting in the sun keeping me company – that simple act of marriage – while I weed and muse…
The time: Ash Wednesday, February 1996. The place: worship in the chapel at St. Boniface Hospital in Winnipeg, Manitoba. Sitting there, eyes closed, the words of the service washing over me but not really sinking in until suddenly the singing of the psalm refrain began to filter through. The voices lifted in prayer were singing “Mon Dieu, donnez moi un coeur nouveau….”
I struggled with the meaning of Lent this year. With the wars and so many conflicts in our own town, country, and the world, I wondered what my Lenten practices should be? Would fasting from food help in a world full of suffering and uncertainties? What should be my prayer focus? What should I do as almsgiving for Lent this year?
We first wrote “twelve hours of daylight” in 2016 as part of an anthology (FEAST) of spoken word poems that are still unpublished. Like most of our work, we take our deep love of the scriptures and weave them together to speak to current realities. In this particular poem, there are a few references to cities, including Vancouver and Montreal, where we were living at the time of writing…
It’s been two years since the world began shutting down where I live in Saskatoon. My Facebook and google photo memories have been popping up these past few weeks with the events that I still remember as the last time I did this or that.
I see the memory of my gratitude for my birthday gathering and I can’t help but think “ahh, the last party we threw.” …
When Amy asked me to write a reflection about Lent, I wasn't sure if I would do it. To be honest I wasn't sure if I was qualified to do this as my first “real” introduction to Lent was from people around the New Leaf table and my mother-in-law. Because in my tradition, we don't really observe Lent. Growing up in Texas, I thought it was only for Catholic people to do…
Most years I have come to long for Lent, and this year perhaps more than most. I’m not sure how I was first initiated into practicing this season but it likely began with noticing the change in liturgical colours decorating my rural Protestant church. Purple must have captured my imagination…
Each Good Friday and Easter, I have this strange habit of checking to see if the weather matches the theological mood of the day. Will Good Friday be gloomy and rainy? Will Easter be bright and sunny, preferably after a few gloomy days?
Lent invites us into a process of letting go. Perhaps this is most commonly expressed in the practice of fasting traditionally associated with this season. But now, as we enter Holy Week, this reflection invites us to consider letting go in a different way . . .
We were five minutes into the woods, less than ten minutes away from a busy street. All I could hear were the ins and outs of my breath, the soft crunching of snow beneath my feet, the blowing snow, and the sound of squirrels chattering, when, suddenly, blissful silence. Not even the whistling of the wind could be heard…
I’ve always needed Lent in a personal way. I have a tendency to fill my plate to overflowing—drawn to every flavour and texture and combination. Wanting to savour every bit, but also rushing to the next so quickly that the richness of each is often compromised…